Thursday, July 02, 2009

Oldies But Goodies


An article in today's NY Times got me reminiscing about operating on old folks. While it's true there is inherently increased surgical risk in their care, my list of favorite patients is heavily populated with the elderly.

Like the ninety-six year old who lived with a very cumbersome hernia because he'd been told repairing it would be too risky. He had some friends over for a truss-burning party after I fixed it under local anesthesia. Or the WWII vet, rejected by other surgeons for his age and (only slightly) less than perfect heart, who told me I'd replaced Douglas MacArthur as his hero after I cured his debilitating reflux esophagitis. The many many older women who took their breast cancer in stride; the sturdy lady who fought tooth and nail, literally walked out on me, when I first told her she needed a colostomy but who finally acceded and insisted on seeing me bi-annually forever afterwards, bringing treats from her garden every time.

The oldest I ever operated on was a Russian immigrant from a town in the Ural Mountains where they live half way to forever. He was 102, which was lower than his temperature, caused by a gallstone stuck in his bile duct. His family assured me he was sharp as saber and strong as slivovitz. Two weeks later, he was back working his garden.

It was always my impression that older people were more matter-of-fact about their illnesses, and I found it almost universally true that they were less troubled with post-operative pain. Maybe it was physiological; maybe because they were more sensitive to narcotics. But I always thought it was simply because they'd made it through the better part of a hard life and pain just wasn't that big of a deal any more.

For an older person, the default mode was trust (the "sturdy" lady excepted. Sort of.) They listened when I talked. "Do what you think is best, Doctor," they said, which was like flopping into a comfy chair, after a day of walking on nails. It's impossible to care for the gray-haired and not think of grandparents, not to relax a little, to feel respect.

Okay, in the intensive care unit, not so much. Called there to consult, finding an ancient-looking person, tubes in natural and unnatural orifices, knowing survival odds are in inverse relation to those tubes, one is faced with often impossible questions having unknowable answers. To do what is reasonable; certainly no less, but hopefully no more. And humane. But that's another matter, with not just immediate but global implications (health care costs!). I was talking about the sort of relationship that begins in the office, or maybe a regular hospital bed. Relaxed. Time to get to know each other.

The NYT article points out some ways in which the geriatric population differs from the younger. (It also makes the very good point that whereas all med students do time in pediatrics, obstetrics, etc, there's no requirement for geriatrics. Older folks aren't just wrinkly.) It's certainly true in terms of length of recovery time, healing issues, complications from accompanying disease. I wish there were objective ways to measure risk, to predict outcomes. Absent that, I always found a couple of reliable -- if unscientific -- predictors: people do like they look. An eighty year old who looks fifty will recover like a fifty year old; a fifty year old who looks eighty will recover like eighty. And, no matter what age, anyone who walks a mile or two every day will do just fine.

15 comments:

Sili said...

I am soooo dead ...


I really wish young doctors could (and would) be mentored properly with gems like this.

Ellen Kimball said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Sid Schwab said...

This is a comment from loyal reader, Ellen Kimball. I edited it slightly for reasons she'll understand. No biggie, Ellen.

What a tribute to those of us who have some mileage on us! I loved the truss burning party! Funny and delightful!

My husband had one hernia repaired several years ago. No problems. Done on an out-patient basis. Then the other one popped out, much to the surgeon's chagrin. (He had predicted it would not be a problem.) The second was fixed with no difficulty.

I donated hubby's truss to a medical charity here in Tigard, OR.

Best wishes to you and your family for a happy, healthy, hearty 4th of July.

Ellen & the DigiPix_Man

Adjuster Mike said...

Are you serious about the walking thing?

Sid Schwab said...

Mike: yes. Particularly an older person who says he or she walks every day. But for anyone, some form of regular exercise makes a notable difference in tolerance of and recovery from surgery. I think I've seen studies to that effect as well, but, in the context of this post, it's a personal observation.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for imparting pearls of surgical wisdom on "the intrawebs". They're not being wasted.

I'm going for a walk now.

Regards,
Precordial Thump

p.s. Would it be rude to request a blog on the increasing trend toward specialization in surgery, extinction of the true general surgeon, and whether you think it's a good or a bad trend?

Sid Schwab said...

PT: I've been ruminating about that subject, although I did address it to a degree in a previous post.

AlisonH said...

As a colectomy patient as of January, I understand that woman walking out at first--I wanted to do the same thing, till it became clear it was a "your colon or your life" decision. Oh! Well in that case, hey!

I love this post. Thank you for writing it. It made me think fondly of my grandfather, who walked seven miles a day to work at his office in DC and by his mid-80's kept doing at least two miles a day till I think 92.

At which point he became an instant old man, and suddenly a diabetic, too. Made it to 95.

Frank Drackman said...

How come Old peoples innards don't look Old??? Or can you tell an 80 yr old mesentery from a 20 year olds??? All looks like chitlins to me....

Sid Schwab said...

Frank, I wrote about that very thing a while back.

larry said...

Sid:

The walking works. Simple, cheap, easy to do, no contracts needed. no machine required. Following a pretty decent heart attack, the basic program I followed was walk every day. Up to 2-3miles a day now with some diet changes thrown into the mix. Still enjoy the occasional steak, hamburger, fries, and what have you, but not on a daily basis. Total cholesterol went from 195 to 120. Triglycerides now 56. HDL 42. LDL 69.

Who knew?

Forget the Kennedy assassination, that Obama was born elsewhere, that 9/11 was an inside job. The biggest conspiracy is that they're hiding walking from us all.

Larry

Larry said...

Oh...did I mention the 35 pounds that went away too?

Ye gads, it can't be this easy.

Larry

SeaSpray said...

great post Dr S!

What do you recommend for people with chronic knee pain?

ZMD said...

As an anesthesiologist, I used to be terrifed by the very elderly patients. I remember a patient I had soon after finishing residency, a 102 y/o for hip replacement. I put in every monitor I could think of, got every cardiac workup available. In the end, she did great, no different than a 60 y/o. Since then, I've realized that if they can live to 100 y/o, their cardiac and pulmonary functions are probably pretty durable and unlikely to fail during surgery, barring extreme complications.

sufeiyasworld said...

i love your insight on patients,
i always think the patients attitude and trust in the doctor takes a great part in the healing process. ! good to keep in mind for my intern year :)